Will Dry Rotted Tires Pass Inspection? Signs, Risks, and Prevention Tips

by

Dry rotted tires will not pass inspection. Inspectors look for tread depth of at least 1/32 inch. They also check for dry rot, cuts that expose belts, bubbles, and shifted belts. Any of these issues indicate tire failure and safety concerns. Ensure your tires are in good condition to meet inspection criteria.

The risks of driving on dry rotted tires are significant. Cracks can lead to tire failure, increasing the chance of accidents. In addition, dry rot reduces traction and handling, especially in wet conditions. This condition endangers the driver, passengers, and other road users.

Preventing dry rot is essential for tire safety. Regularly check tire pressure and ensure proper inflation. Store tires in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Additionally, apply tire protectants that can help retain moisture. Rotate your tires regularly to promote even wear and extend their lifespan.

By addressing the signs and risks of dry rotted tires, drivers can maintain safety at all times. Understanding how to care for and inspect tires will ensure you are prepared for your next inspection. Next, we will explore how to identify dry rot and how to choose the right tires to prevent this issue.

What Are Dry Rotted Tires and How Do They Form?

Dry rotted tires are tires that have deteriorated due to age and exposure to environmental conditions. This deterioration leads to cracks and brittleness in the rubber, compromising the tire’s integrity and safety.

The main points related to dry rotted tires are as follows:
1. Definition of dry rot
2. Causes of dry rot formation
3. Signs of dry rotted tires
4. Risks associated with using dry rotted tires
5. Prevention methods for dry rot

Understanding these points helps in recognizing the dangers of dry rotted tires and knowing how to maintain tire health effectively.

  1. Definition of Dry Rot: Dry rot refers to the degradation of tire rubber that primarily results from the loss of moisture content over time. This process leads to a significant reduction in elasticity, causing the rubber to become hard and develop cracks. According to a study by the Rubber Manufacturers Association (RMA), tire life expectancy averages between six to ten years. Beyond this period, tires are susceptible to dry rot.

  2. Causes of Dry Rot Formation: Dry rot formation happens due to several factors. Key causes include prolonged exposure to ultraviolet (UV) rays from sunlight, changes in temperature, and lack of use. Additionally, certain chemicals and contaminants, such as oil or gasoline, can accelerate the drying process of the rubber. A 2020 study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) highlighted that tires stored in a humid environment or under direct sunlight face higher risks of deterioration.

  3. Signs of Dry Rotted Tires: Signs of dry rotted tires include visible cracks in the sidewalls, a chalky texture, and a loss of flexibility. Drivers should also check for bulges or deformities, which can indicate further damage. Regular inspections can help identify these signs early. As noted by automotive expert John H. in a 2021 article, drivers should not overlook these signs, as neglecting them can lead to tire failure on the road.

  4. Risks Associated With Using Dry Rotted Tires: Using dry rotted tires poses significant risks, including blowouts and reduced traction, especially in wet conditions. Neglected tires may lead to accidents due to compromised handling and braking capabilities. The NHTSA reports that tire-related crashes account for approximately 30% of all vehicle accidents. Tire safety is crucial for both driver safety and overall road conditions.

  5. Prevention Methods for Dry Rot: To prevent dry rot, vehicle owners should store tires in a cool, dry place away from sunlight. Regularly rotating and using tires can maintain their elasticity. Additionally, applying tire dressings can provide a protective layer against UV rays. The International Tire and Rubber Association (ITRA) recommends conducting routine checks every month for signs of wear and keeping tires inflated to the manufacturer’s specifications.

How Can You Identify Dry Rotted Tires?

You can identify dry rotted tires by inspecting for cracks, checking for brittleness, examining tire age, and looking at visual signs of deterioration.

To elaborate on these identification methods, consider the following points:

  • Cracks: Look for visible cracks in the sidewalls and tread. These cracks can appear as small lines or larger fissures. A study by the Rubber Manufacturers Association (2021) indicates that such cracks can compromise the tire’s structural integrity.

  • Brittleness: Press on the tire’s surface. If the rubber feels hard and does not flex easily, it may be dry rotted. This brittleness occurs due to loss of moisture and flexibility as tires age.

  • Tire Age: Check the manufacturing date. Most tire manufacturers recommend replacing tires every six years, regardless of tread wear. This advice stems from research showing that rubber degrades over time, even without visible usage.

  • Visual Signs: Look for discoloration or a chalky appearance on the tire. This happens when the rubber compound breaks down due to exposure to UV rays and environmental factors. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) notes these visual indications as critical warning signs.

  • Tread Condition: Inspect the tread for excessive uneven wear. A well-worn tread may indicate that the tire has lost its ability to grip the road, which is further aggravated by dry rot.

By carefully examining these factors, vehicle owners can effectively identify dry rotted tires, preventing potential hazards on the road.

What Are the Warning Signs of Dry Rotted Tires?

The warning signs of dry rotted tires include visible cracks, hard or brittle surface texture, loss of elasticity, and discoloration. Recognizing these signs can prevent dangerous driving conditions.

  1. Visible Cracks
  2. Hard or Brittle Surface
  3. Loss of Elasticity
  4. Discoloration

Understanding the implications of these signs is essential for safe vehicle operation. The effects of dry rotted tires can range from poor vehicle performance to dangerous blowouts on the road.

  1. Visible Cracks: Visible cracks indicate potential structural failure. These cracks may appear on the sidewall or tread of the tire. They develop due to the rubber degrading over time, often exacerbated by exposure to sunlight and ozone. A 2019 study by the Rubber Manufacturers Association illustrates that tires can start to crack after six years of service, leading to compromised safety.

  2. Hard or Brittle Surface: A hard or brittle surface is a sign that the rubber has lost its flexibility. Tires should have a supple feel. According to a study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), stiffness in tire rubber can increase the risk of reduced traction and poor handling, particularly in wet conditions.

  3. Loss of Elasticity: Loss of elasticity means the tires cannot adequately absorb shocks. Tires should flex slightly when in use; when they cannot, it affects ride comfort and vehicle control. The University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute states that a loss of elasticity can lead to premature tire failure, which is critical, especially on highways.

  4. Discoloration: Discoloration indicates chemical degradation of the rubber. Tires that turn brown or have a chalky appearance are at risk. This change can occur from prolonged exposure to UV rays and pollutants. In a 2020 report, the International Journal of Automotive Technology highlighted that discoloration is often an early warning sign that warrants inspection and potential replacement.

Being aware of these signs will help maintain tire safety and vehicle performance. Regular checks can prevent accidents and extend the lifespan of your tires.

How Can You Inspect Tires for Cracks and Damage?

You can inspect tires for cracks and damage by examining the sidewalls, tread, and overall condition while looking for specific signs of wear or deterioration.

To effectively inspect tires, follow these key points:

  1. Inspect Sidewalls: Check for visible cracks or cuts. Sidewall damage can compromise tire integrity. Small cracks may indicate dryness or age. Larger cuts can lead to air loss or blowouts. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) advises inspecting sidewalls regularly.

  2. Examine Tread Depth: Use the penny test to measure tread wear. Insert a penny into the tread with Lincoln’s head facing down. If you can see the top of his head, the tread is too worn. The NHTSA recommends a tread depth of at least 2/32 of an inch for safe driving.

  3. Look for Bulges or Blisters: Bulges or blisters on the tire surface indicate internal damage. These imperfections can lead to tire failure. According to a study by the National Tire Dealers Association (NTDA), tires showing such defects should be replaced immediately.

  4. Check for Uneven Wear: Inspect tread patterns for inconsistencies. Uneven wear can signal alignment issues, improper inflation, or suspension problems. The Rubber Manufacturers Association (RMA) suggests regular rotation of tires to prevent uneven wear.

  5. Monitor Age of Tires: Consider the tire’s age, not just its appearance. Tires should be replaced every six years, regardless of tread wear, according to the Tire Industry Association (TIA). Look for the DOT code on the sidewall to find the manufacturing date.

  6. Inspect Valve Stems: Check for cracks or brittleness in the valve stem. A damaged valve stem can cause air leaks. The TIA recommends replacing damaged valve stems when installing new tires.

Regularly checking your tires for these signs can help ensure safe driving and prolong tire life.

Why Is the Age of Tires Important in Assessing Dry Rot?

The age of tires is crucial when assessing dry rot because older tires have a higher likelihood of developing this condition. Dry rot, also known as weather checking, occurs when rubber tires lose moisture and start to crack.

According to the Tire Industry Association, tires typically have a shelf life of about six years, but they can remain in service for up to ten years if maintained properly. This underscores the importance of regularly checking tire age, as it plays a significant role in their integrity and safety.

The underlying reason why tire age affects dry rot primarily lies in the degradation of rubber compounds over time. As tires age, they can lose elasticity and moisture. This process is accelerated by exposure to environmental factors like sunlight, heat, and ozone.

Dry rot refers to the cracking and deterioration of rubber tires. It occurs when tires dry out due to prolonged exposure to air and ultraviolet (UV) radiation, breaking down the tire’s chemical structure and leading to potential safety hazards.

One major mechanism involved in dry rot is oxidation. Oxygen interacts with tire materials, causing them to become brittle. This is compounded by factors like heat. Higher temperatures can further accelerate the rate at which the rubber deteriorates.

Specific conditions that contribute to the risk of dry rot include frequent exposure to extreme temperatures and UV light, insufficient storage conditions, and lack of maintenance. For example, tires stored outside without protection from sunlight are more prone to develop dry rot compared to those stored in a shaded, cool environment. Regular inspections can help detect early signs of dry rot, such as cracking on the tire’s surface, allowing for timely replacement and maintaining safety on the road.

Will Dry Rotted Tires Pass Vehicle Inspection?

No, dry rotted tires will not pass vehicle inspection. Tires with dry rot indicate degradation that can compromise safety.

Dry rot occurs when tires become brittle and cracked due to prolonged exposure to air, heat, and UV light. This deterioration weakens the tire structure, affecting performance and safety. During a vehicle inspection, officials typically check the overall condition of tires, including tread depth and signs of damage. Tires that show significant cracking or weathering will be deemed unsafe, resulting in a failed inspection. Maintaining proper tire care and timely replacement is essential for safety and compliance.

What Criteria Do Inspectors Use to Evaluate Tire Condition?

Inspectors evaluate tire condition using several key criteria. These criteria help determine the safety and performance of tires on vehicles.

  1. Tread Depth
  2. Sidewall Condition
  3. Uniform Wear
  4. Tire Age
  5. Air Pressure
  6. Punctures and Cuts
  7. Visible Damage

Understanding the criteria used for tire evaluation is essential. Each point provides insight into the overall health and safety of tires.

  1. Tread Depth: Inspectors analyze the tread depth to ensure it meets minimum safety standards. Tread depth affects traction, particularly in wet conditions. The minimum legal limit is typically 2/32 of an inch in most regions. Inadequate tread can lead to hydroplaning or loss of control.

  2. Sidewall Condition: The sidewall is examined for any cracks, bulges, or separations. These defects can indicate structural failure or internal damage. A study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) found that sidewall defects are a common cause of tire blowouts.

  3. Uniform Wear: Inspectors check for uneven or irregular tire wear. This condition may signal alignment or suspension issues. Uneven wear decreases tire lifespan and can lead to handling issues. Regular tire rotation can help mitigate these problems.

  4. Tire Age: Inspectors look at the manufacturing date, typically found on the tire’s sidewall. Tires should generally be replaced every six to ten years, even if there is sufficient tread. Aging tires could pose safety risks due to rubber deterioration.

  5. Air Pressure: Correct tire inflation is crucial for performance and safety. Inspectors measure tire pressure against the manufacturer’s recommended levels. Under-inflated tires can lead to blowouts, while over-inflated tires may decrease traction.

  6. Punctures and Cuts: Inspectors assess tires for punctures or cuts that could affect safety. A puncture can lead to air loss, while significant cuts might compromise tire integrity. Tires with severe damage should be replaced to ensure safety.

  7. Visible Damage: Inspectors look for any obvious damage that affects tire safety. This includes significant abrasions, tears, or foreign objects embedded in the tire. Any visible damage warrants immediate attention and potentially tire replacement.

Each criterion plays a vital role in ensuring the overall safety and efficiency of vehicle tires. Regular inspections and maintenance can prolong tire life and enhance driving safety.

What Risks Are Associated with Driving on Dry Rotted Tires?

Driving on dry rotted tires poses significant safety risks. These risks include blowouts, loss of traction, decreased handling, and compromised braking performance.

  1. Blowouts
  2. Loss of traction
  3. Decreased handling
  4. Compromised braking performance

Understanding the risks associated with dry rotted tires is essential for safe driving.

  1. Blowouts: Dry rotted tires are prone to blowouts due to weakened rubber. This deterioration decreases the tire’s structural integrity. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), tire blowouts contribute to nearly 11,000 vehicle crashes annually. A blowout can occur suddenly, leading to loss of vehicle control.

  2. Loss of Traction: Dry rot affects the tire tread, making it difficult for tires to grip the road. This loss of traction increases the risk of skidding, especially in wet or slippery conditions. A study published by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) explains that tires with insufficient tread depth can increase stopping distances significantly.

  3. Decreased Handling: Tires in poor condition can affect vehicle handling. Drivers may notice less responsive steering and instability, particularly during turns. Research by the Tire Industry Association (TIA) suggests that degraded tires can lead to difficulty in maintaining a straight line, affecting overall driving performance.

  4. Compromised Braking Performance: Dry rotted tires can impair a vehicle’s braking ability. Reduced rubber flexibility leads to increased braking distances, making it difficult to stop promptly in an emergency. According to a 2021 study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS), vehicles equipped with well-maintained tires can stop up to 30% shorter than those with compromised tires.

Regular inspection and maintenance of tires are crucial. Drivers should be aware of signs of dry rot such as cracks, discoloration, or brittleness to ensure safe driving conditions.

How Do Dry Rotted Tires Impact Road Safety?

Dry rotted tires significantly compromise road safety by increasing the risks of blowouts, reducing traction, and impairing vehicle control. Understanding these impacts can help drivers make informed decisions about tire maintenance.

  • Increased risk of blowouts: Dry rot degrades the tire’s structure and materials. According to a study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), tire blowouts contribute to approximately 10,000 crashes annually in the United States (NHTSA, 2020). A blowout occurs when the tire fails suddenly, often resulting in loss of vehicle control.

  • Reduced traction: Dry rotting causes the tire rubber to harden and crack, leading to diminished grip on the road surface. Research by the Tire Manufacturers Association indicates that a tire’s effectiveness in channeling water and maintaining contact with the road is directly related to its tread condition. A compromised tread due to dry rot can significantly reduce the tire’s ability to perform effectively in wet conditions, increasing the likelihood of skidding or hydroplaning.

  • Impaired vehicle control: When tires are dry rotted, they can experience uneven wear patterns. This uneven distribution of contact with the road can affect steering responsiveness and cornering capabilities. A study published in the Journal of Transportation Engineering noted that vehicles with poorly maintained tires face higher incidents of loss of control during sudden maneuvers (Smith & Jones, 2019).

Regular inspection and maintenance of tires can mitigate these risks. Drivers should routinely check for signs of dry rot, such as cracks, discoloration, or excessive wear. By prioritizing tire health, motorists can enhance their safety on the road.

What Consequences Can Arise from Ignoring Dry Rotted Tires?

Ignoring dry rotted tires can lead to significant safety hazards and financial consequences.

The main consequences of ignoring dry rotted tires include:
1. Increased risk of tire blowouts
2. Decreased vehicle handling and stability
3. Reduced fuel efficiency
4. Higher repair costs due to further vehicle damage
5. Potential legal liabilities in case of accidents

Addressing the consequences of dry rotted tires is essential for maintaining vehicle safety and performance.

  1. Increased Risk of Tire Blowouts:
    Ignoring dry rotted tires increases the likelihood of tire blowouts. Dry rot weakens the tire’s material. This degradation compromises the tire’s structural integrity. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), tire blowouts contribute to over 78,000 crashes annually in the U.S. A case study by the AAA revealed that 31% of drivers do not check their tire’s condition regularly, increasing the risks of blowouts.

  2. Decreased Vehicle Handling and Stability:
    Dry rotted tires negatively affect a vehicle’s handling and stability. Cracks in the rubber can cause uneven wear, leading to poor grip on the road. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) states that tires with inadequate grip increase the chances of skidding during adverse weather conditions. Studies by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) suggest that compromised handling often results in a higher accident rate during rainy or snowy conditions.

  3. Reduced Fuel Efficiency:
    Dry rotted tires can reduce fuel efficiency. Tires with dry rot may have a higher rolling resistance. The U.S. Department of Energy reports that under-inflated or degraded tires can lower fuel efficiency by 10%. This inefficiency leads to increased fuel costs over time.

  4. Higher Repair Costs Due to Further Vehicle Damage:
    Ignoring dry rotted tires may lead to additional vehicle damage. A blown tire can harm other components, such as the suspension or bodywork, resulting in costly repairs. According to a survey by AAA, the average cost of tire replacement is around $100 to $300, but related repairs can escalate quickly, totaling thousands of dollars.

  5. Potential Legal Liabilities in Case of Accidents:
    Neglecting the condition of dry rotted tires can expose drivers to legal liabilities in accidents. If a vehicle accident occurs due to tire failure, the driver may be held responsible. A report by the American Bar Association indicates that insurance claims related to tire failure can increase premiums significantly, leading to financial repercussions beyond immediate repair costs.

Overall, dry rotted tires present multiple serious consequences. Understanding these risks encourages drivers to prioritize tire maintenance and safety to avoid significant hazards and expenses.

How Can You Prevent Tire Dry Rot?

You can prevent tire dry rot by regularly inspecting your tires, storing vehicles properly, maintaining proper tire pressure, and protecting tires from UV exposure.

Regular inspections: Conduct routine checks on your tires to catch signs of dry rot early. Look for cracks, hardening, or discoloration. A study by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA, 2021) recommends monthly tire inspections to ensure safety and longevity.

Proper storage: If you store a vehicle for an extended period, keep it indoors if possible. Indoor storage protects tires from environmental elements. If indoor storage is not an option, use tire covers to shield them from sun and wind exposure.

Proper tire pressure: Maintaining the correct tire pressure is vital. Under-inflated tires can lead to excessive flexing, which contributes to wear and potential dry rot. The Tire Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) alerts the driver when tire pressure is low. According to the Rubber Manufacturers Association (RMA, 2022), every 1 psi loss can reduce fuel efficiency.

UV protection: Ultraviolet (UV) rays cause rubber to deteriorate over time. Consider applying a tire protectant or dressing that contains UV inhibitors. Research by the American Chemical Society (ACS, 2020) indicates that these protectants can significantly extend the lifespan of tires by preventing degradation from UV exposure.

In summary, focusing on these key preventive measures can significantly reduce the risk of tire dry rot. Regular inspections, proper storage, maintaining tire pressure, and protecting tires from UV rays are crucial actions for tire care.

What Maintenance Tips Can Extend the Life of Your Tires?

The maintenance tips that can extend the life of your tires include regular inspections, proper inflation, rotation, alignment, and balancing.

  1. Regular Inspections
  2. Proper Tire Inflation
  3. Tire Rotation
  4. Wheel Alignment
  5. Tire Balancing
  6. Avoid Overloading
  7. Driving Habits
  8. Tire Storage

To understand how each of these tips contributes to tire longevity, let’s explore them in detail.

  1. Regular Inspections: Conducting regular inspections involves visually checking tires for signs of wear and damage. Look for cracks, bulges, or foreign objects stuck in the tread. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), approximately 10% of all tire-related incidents stem from neglecting regular checks. A consistent inspection routine can identify issues early, preventing premature tire failure.

  2. Proper Tire Inflation: Keeping your tires properly inflated ensures optimal contact with the road, which enhances safety and efficiency. Under-inflated tires can decrease fuel economy by 0.2% for every 1 PSI drop in pressure, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. Aim for the recommended tire pressure found in your vehicle’s owner manual or the driver’s side door jamb.

  3. Tire Rotation: Tire rotation involves switching the position of your tires to promote even wear. Most experts recommend rotating tires every 5,000 to 8,000 miles. This practice helps maintain balanced handling and can extend tread life. A study by the Tire Industry Association shows that rotating tires consistently can improve a tire’s lifespan by up to 20%.

  4. Wheel Alignment: Proper wheel alignment ensures that all four tires meet the road at the correct angle. Misalignment can cause uneven tire wear and handling issues. The NHTSA suggests checking alignment at least once a year or whenever you notice uneven wear patterns. Proper alignment can increase tire life by minimizing unnecessary friction.

  5. Tire Balancing: Tire balancing involves adjusting the distribution of weight within the tire. Unbalanced tires may lead to vibrations, uneven wear, and damage to suspension components. Many technicians recommend balancing tires every time they are mounted or rotated. A balanced tire can improve fuel efficiency by ensuring consistent contact with the road surface.

  6. Avoid Overloading: Overloading your vehicle can strain tires beyond their designed capacity. Each tire has a specified load rating, which can be found on the sidewall. Exceeding this limit can lead to blowouts or premature wear. According to a 2019 study, operating a vehicle with overloaded tires increases the risk of tire failure by 30%.

  7. Driving Habits: Adopting safe driving habits can significantly impact tire lifespan. Avoiding sudden accelerations, hard braking, and aggressive cornering can reduce tire wear. Research conducted by the Institute for Highway Safety underscores how driving behavior accounts for a substantial percentage of tire-related accidents.

  8. Tire Storage: If you switch between seasonal tires, proper storage is crucial. Store tires in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight and extreme temperatures. Using breathable bags helps prevent moisture buildup. Manufacturers suggest that proper storage practices can extend tire life by preventing degradation from UV exposure.

By incorporating these maintenance tips into your routine, you can significantly enhance the longevity and safety of your tires.

Which Environmental Factors Contribute to Tire Aging and Dry Rot?

Environmental factors that contribute to tire aging and dry rot include exposure to heat, sunlight, ozone, and humidity.

  1. UV radiation from sunlight
  2. High temperatures
  3. Ozone exposure
  4. Humidity and moisture
  5. Chemical exposure
  6. Tire age and wear
  7. Improper storage conditions

These environmental factors can interact and compound their effects, leading to a complex relationship that influences tire health over time.

  1. UV Radiation from Sunlight: UV radiation from sunlight significantly contributes to tire aging. Ultraviolet rays can break down the chemical bonds in tire rubber, leading to surface cracks and dry rot. A study by the American Chemical Society indicated that prolonged UV exposure can degrade tire performance over time.

  2. High Temperatures: High temperatures accelerate the aging process of tires. Heat causes tire materials to expand and contract, which can lead to internal deterioration. According to the Rubber Manufacturers Association, continual exposure to temperatures above 70°F can significantly decrease a tire’s lifespan.

  3. Ozone Exposure: Ozone in the atmosphere reacts with the rubber compounds in tires. This reaction can cause surface cracking and is often exacerbated by heat. The Environmental Protection Agency states that ozone affects rubber more at elevated temperatures, making tires more susceptible to damage.

  4. Humidity and Moisture: Humidity can contribute to tire degradation. Excess moisture can lead to mold and rot. Miklós P. Kerekes, a tire specialist, explains that tires stored in damp environments are more prone to degradation.

  5. Chemical Exposure: Chemicals from road surfaces, such as oils, fuels, and solvents, can harm tires. These substances can seep into the rubber and damage its integrity. A report by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration highlights the importance of avoiding exposure to such chemicals for tire longevity.

  6. Tire Age and Wear: Older tires are more susceptible to dry rot. The materials in tires degrade over time, regardless of usage. According to the Tire Industry Association, tires that are over six years old should be inspected regularly for signs of aging.

  7. Improper Storage Conditions: Tires stored improperly can suffer from accelerated aging. Exposure to direct sunlight, extreme temperatures, or excessive moisture can lead to deterioration. The Tire Rack advises storing tires in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and chemicals to prolong their life.

These environmental factors collectively influence the overall health and safety of tires. Understanding these contributors can help tire users manage and extend the lifespan of their tires effectively.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment